South Africa: Constitutional Assembly Resources Support SAFLII

You are here:  SAFLII >> Databases >> South Africa: Constitutional Assembly Resources >> 1994 >> [1994] ZAConAsmRes 12

| Noteup | LawCite

Citizen Contribution: G Braasch [1994] ZAConAsmRes 12 (18 January 1994)

 

G Braasch

18/1/1994


I would like to bring up a matter that has been widely commented on already, since it was also accepted in the draft constitution. It concerns the matter of penalties for crimes committed, especially murder, rape, violent assault, these serious crimes becoming so popular nowadays.

I feel that a person doing something to somebody else must realize that the punishment is severe, definitely not less than what you are doing to your victim. This implicates that the death penalty must be kept for murder.

I propose further that a convict should not have normal rights as a law-abiding person, the right to vote for instance. Part of the penalty should be the loss of normal rights, temporary removal from society alone is not enough.

Since it seems that imprisonment today is not a deterrent to crime, I would suggest hard labour and canning be reintroduced. If this approach can work in Singapore, it will most probably also have better results in this country.

The main point I want to make is that white collar crimes, fraud etc. is less severely punishable than those mentioned at the beginning. Today one finds that these crimes are punished harder in comparison.

G BRAASCH