South Africa: Rules and Practice Notes of Superior Courts Support SAFLII

You are here:  SAFLII >> Databases >> South Africa: Rules and Practice Notes of Superior Courts >> 2022 >> [2022] ZARC 1

| Noteup | LawCite

Notice to all Litigation Attorneys in Gauteng in re: Clarification of Civil Trial Roll Process: Johannesburg [2022] ZARC 1 (3 February 2022)

Download original files

PDF format

RTF format


 

 

OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY JUDGE PRESIDENT

 

(HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA, GAUTENG DIVISION, JOHANNESBURG) OFFICE 1210

 

Telephone number: 011 335 0116/011 335 0162 / 011 335 0163

Fax number:  (011) 335 0219

e-mail address: Secretarydjp@judiciary.org.za / LTulleken@judiciary.org.za

 

 

N O T I C E

 

 

TO

 

1.            Chief Registrar

2.            Registrar: Civil Trials

3.            Legal Practice Council – Gauteng

4.            Law Society of South Africa

5.            Gauteng Family Law Forum

6.            Gauteng Attorneys Association

7.            Pretoria Attorneys Association

8.            Johannesburg Attorneys Association

9.            West Rand Attorneys Association

10.         South African Black Women in Law

11.         National Association of Democratic Lawyers

12.         Black Lawyers Association

13.         South African Women Lawyers Association

14.         South African Medical Malpractice Lawyers Association

15.         Personal Injury Plaintiff Lawyers Association

16.         South African Medico-Legal Association

17.         Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, Pretoria and Johannesburg

18.         Office of the State Attorneys, Pretoria and Johannesburg

19.         Solicitor General

20.         Office of the Family Advocate, Pretoria and Johannesburg

21.         Legal Aid South Africa

22.         Johannesburg Society of Advocates

23.         Pretoria Society of Advocates

24.         Gauteng Society of Advocates

25.         Pan African Bar Association of South Africa

26.         General Council of the Bar of South Africa

27.         National Bar Council of South Africa

28.         South African Bar Association

29.         National Forum of Advocates

30.         North Gauteng Association of Advocates

31.         Church Square Association of Advocates

32.         Advocates for Transformation

33.         Legal Division of the Department of Health: Gauteng

34.         Legal Division of the Department of Sport, Arts, Culture and Recreation

35.         Gauteng Department of Agriculture and Rural Development

36.         Legal Services - Gauteng Provincial Department of Education:

 

 DATE :           03 February 2022

 

RE      :           NOTICE TO ALL LITIGATION ATTORNEYS IN GAUTENG in re CLARIFICATION OF CIVIL TRIAL ROLL PROCESS: JOHANNESBURG

 

 

 

1.            The civil trial roll call procedure is regulated by the Judge President’s Directive of 11 June 2021, a copy of which is accessible on CaseLines.

 

2.            The relevant portion reads thus: “THE CIVIL TRIAL ROLL CALL

[37]. There shall be no physical roll call. The current practice of civil trial allocation shall continue for the duration of the national state of disaster, provided that where it is deemed appropriate by the roll call Judge, a virtual roll call may be convened with specific directives.

 

Practice Note required

[38]. The Parties shall upload, in the correct section, a JOINT PRACTICE NOTE after a special pre-trial conference, at which the logistics of conducting the trial are addressed, was convened. If a Plaintiff cannot obtain cooperation from a Defendant, the Plaintiff must upload its own practice note and explain why a joint practice note was impossible to be composed. A Defendant may in this instance elect to upload its own practice note and explain why a joint practice note was impossible to be composed. Lack of co-operation by either Party shall attract punitive orders by the Court.

[39]. The practice note must be uploaded by not later than 5 court days before the set-down date. If no practice note is timeously uploaded, the matter shall automatically be removed and the date forfeited. If the practice note is non- compliant with the practice manual or this directive, the matter shall be automatically removed and similarly the date forfeited. This directive shall be strictly applied.

.

[40]. The practice note must, in addition to the information required in terms of the practice manual, address these issues: The names, email addresses and cell numbers of all Counsel. Counsel must hold themselves ready to receive a communication from a Judge or Judge’s Secretary, during the four days until set down date.”

 

3.            The underlined passages are the relevant portions addressed in this memo.

 

4.            Implicit in the process envisioned is that shortly before the set down date the parties should meet in a “special pre-trial conference” to address how the trial is to be run. Para 38 does not, however, expressly stipulate exactly when this meeting should take place.

 

5.            Para 39 states that a practice note should be uploaded “by not later than 5 court days before the set down date”. The text does not say how long before that 5th day the practice note should be filed.

 

6.            Regrettably, there is indeed ambiguity and this has resulted in different understandings. Holistically read, what is envisaged by this process is a practice note filed shortly before the trial after a last check on whether a trial is necessary at all, and if so, how expeditiously can it be conducted. Axiomatically this assessment can only be made shortly before trial.

 

7.            In several instances, a practice note is filed months before the trial date. This is of no value in declaring the status quo on the eve of trial. When matters are struck off because no recent practice note was filed, parties are understandably disappointed. The recent practice note is critical to the optimal utilisation of court time, and it must therefore be so that it must indeed be recent.

 

8.            To resolve the ambiguity, para 39 shall henceforth read:

 

The practice note must be uploaded not earlier than seven court days before the set down date and not later than five court days before the set down date.”

 

9.            Practitioners should also use the special pre-trial conference as a last opportunity to try to settle the matter, in which case, the matter would be removed from the trial roll and enrolled on the settlement court roll. The draft trial roll is already published by the 7th day before the set down date and, among other reasons, facilitates the Road Accident Fund to be alerted to matters coming up for trial. The Road Accident Fund has undertaken to seize this last chance to settle, if appropriate. Calling for the special pre-trial conference with the Road Accident Fund in these circumstances may prove advantageous to plaintiffs. Even in those matters where the RAF has had its defence struck out, the opportunity to settle at that moment should not be neglected. A call to the Road Accident Fund to engage ought to be considered, rather than routinely proceed, unless the Road Accident Fund itself initiates contact.

 

Yours Faithfully

 

 

 

Dictated by the Deputy Judge President

Electronically transmitted, therefore no signature

 

ROLAND SUTHERLAND DEPUTY JUDGE PRESIDENT