South Africa: Constitutional Assembly Resources Support SAFLII

You are here:  SAFLII >> Databases >> South Africa: Constitutional Assembly Resources >> 1995 >> [1995] ZAConAsmRes 860

| Noteup | LawCite

Validity of Capital Punishment [1995] ZAConAsmRes 860 (16 February 1995)

 

8523514

@EB is SPLOOJEES 852-3514 P.1








Of



9@ 537 LENASIA 4M REPUSUC OF SWH AFRICA

19 (01 11 862-2618 FAX: (01 4) 852-3514

AFFILIAT@S
16 Feh!,kl-%r:l 1995


CAPE PEOVINCE.. H -Daily

0 BIYA COLLEGE
11
PETOWN IN THE NAME OP ALLAH, TRE.MOST MERCIFUL, THE MOST KIND


ATTENTION - MR L MEYER


NATAL PAX NO . (021) 403-22(14

AS-SALA INA
EDUCA'rl )NAL INSTITUTE
BR@EMAP VALIDITY OF CAPITAL P'UWISIIMENT

I
LOCKHA' ISLAMIA
COLLEGE
DUI36AN The injustice of the Apartheid Era unsharnedly took sic e of even the most respected of systems
SIRAATU - HAC 9
ISLAMIC our Legal Systern and through this Penal System

A SCHOOL
ESTCOuvi extended it's vicious tentacles'whereby rqueezing the oppressed even further. Therefore, for those who speak of civil liberties and argue that th inequality in dealing with capital punishment has prejudiced the disadvantaged people, cannot be ignored for the harm is beyond repair nor can the, memory be obliterated or the loss recon-

TRMSI ciled.

ght to life and the viola-

A A D@'IL4E I$LAMIC SCHQQL On the question of the ri
AZAAD)'ILLE tion of constitutional rights seems on for thousands are murdered annually and we

JOHANI ESEIURG MUSLIM $CHOOL argue about the rightful punishment of the
MAY5A R criminal! We however concede that historically the courts were biased and fallible.

LENAS: MUSLIM SCHOOL
LENAS Let us begin by removing those cobwebs and.
emotional academic arguments about constitutional

NURUL SLAM GIRLS S@001
LENAS@,, rights. Crime is n~ed as , an individual
welety. Therefore, crime

and punishment is closely knitted with the nation's
PRETOF IA MUSLIM SCHOOL
LAUDI upholding of the individual-community relationship.


ROSHNIE ISLAMIC SCHOOL
ROSHN:E

PAGE Two/............

~KG IN " PAIN OF A~

The deciding factor whether a criminal should be punished or not is determined by the extent of his/her responsibility for the offences committed. The Mwbrn law or the Penology is based on a social principle since the State is responsible 1. its subjects.

@Therefore Crime goes beyond being an offence to an individual or the community 'belshe lives in, but that it is a violation of the sacred laws of The Almighty. In this respect ; Islam has a unique.theory which combines the beat of both worlds
the State " well as the individual. By in Ow cmtent to @w~ as ~Ppent to Um coromimion of ~ crime. Islam imposes
preventive , ' , emits that has always been the bane to outside critics, but
anything viewed superficially added to improper consideration and fann@ed. by historical prejudices will make Muslim law look barbaric.

The chief mover on justice is the person,who sits to meet out that justice. Islamls chief concern is that the Judge must never compromise his seat, to that extent, that should his belly ache while deliberating on a case, he must remove himself, lest his heads is influenced by his belly. On the carrying out of the laws of the Almighty, the courts are compelled to ascertain that the, crime committed was not MMiab@ or tMt the Mm~ was not ac~ under any obliigation.

,The thiefls hand.must be cut, but such punishment is never inflicted where U~ t the doubt that the thief was i to crime cW of M~. The lictum hasal*ays been that Avoid the e:xectffion of ent by d~.

,slamic concept on crime and punishment is superceded by the instances to
me "det) from circumstances that may lead to crime. Thus after taking such Precaution, Islam prescribes a preventive and just punishment which may be nflicted upon those persons who have no reasonable justification for their crimes ,... death p~ty for mur&r and m- . Am~tion of head for the Peft@ .... sto~ adult," and h~ed h~ for tonlication md death for

~-.Y . Again the punishments are awarded under very strict conditions ;7d benefits ot doubt always goes in favour of the accused. The copus of the Islamic Law is vast and,for this exercise we must contend that the state must @r"te a (3od@fearing society, free from crimes and must take lessons from the ?Peventive Ordinance of Islam.

,awng for the Abolition of the Death Penalty on whatever grounds derails the )asic concept@ of the sacredness of life. @t if auy one:,~ a ,t be for mw~ or.for q~dbg mi~,ef in @'~, it W~ be as if. he he wide and if anyom saved a Nfe, it w"d be as if h-e saved the Ufe

the

w" Quran 5:32,,

gam allows the act of charity to extend and offers the relatives of the slain o exercise their right to grant pardon to,the murderer and settle for blood-money 'he accused is then subjected to some punihment imposed by the judge.

# society cannot treat the cancer that is eating away its life support by merely *eating one Urnb: or "band-aid" some bruise. It must work on every aspect of existence. @ She must feed, clothe and provide heat and shelter to its subjects. must have: dedicated and God-fearing people at its helm and morality and ecency,:, must prevail. It cannot feed its masses through revenue earned in casinos (P state lotteries that has deprived some soW, It cannot. provide homes through 1 rofiteeping in alcohol, and taxing shebeens, It cannot defend the rights of those i rtio take life and stil sleep at peace by denying life to the living foetus.

I'e need to look, deep iii6iide. and admlt th ' at the trakenstein inside us is a laughing t @pocrite that,. has made morality and comm.Qln sense redundant to our modern c ilture. God help us. We are our own destructors .......