South Africa: Constitutional Assembly Resources Support SAFLII

You are here:  SAFLII >> Databases >> South Africa: Constitutional Assembly Resources >> 1995 >> [1995] ZAConAsmRes 1339

| Noteup | LawCite

The Seat of the National Assembly [1995] ZAConAsmRes 1339 (19 May 1995)

 

19 May 1995

THE SEAT OF THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

1. I would suggest that it is premature to call for a change in the seat of the National assembly.
2. The Constitutional Assembly should have a clause in the New Constitution which provides for a possible change in the seat of the National Assembly of the Republic of South Africa but not before 1 year after the New Constitution the work of the Constitutional Assembly has been promulgated under Section 73 of Act 200 1993 and the first fully and exclusively representative government elected installed and fully operational at all levels.
3. The New Constitution should prescribe a procedure for changing the seat of the National Assembly.
4. The new National Assembly can call for changes of the seat of the National Assembly if it is so minded at a more appropriate time .

MOTIVATION

a. The Constitutional Assembly is presently busy with the New Constitution and is concerned with BASIC AND FUNDAMENTAL CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES. A change of the seat of the National Assembly is not a fundamental issue but a method of changing the seat is!
b. By rushing to change the present seat before the New Constitution has been approved introduced and fully operational at all levels the CA would in effect be fixing the goal posts before the playing fields have been levelled and the " Rules of the Game " agreed to .
c. What would happen if the " Front Line States " want closer ties with SA in the future ? The boundaries of RSA were fixed by imperial powers and take no account of the close social economic ethnic and cultural ties that existed before the " Scramble for Africa " as the History books describe the Colonisation of Africa in the 19th Century.
d. There is the matter of expense too . The European Union spent an inordinate amount of time and money in deciding the colour of the new EU passport . Should we not learn from their folly. A change in venue is a much more expensive operation than the change in the colour of a passport .
e. The United States did not start off with Washington as its Capital and the Name was given in tribute to the Father of the American Nation. Perhaps in good time a New Capital City should be laid out hopefully without the mistakes of Brasilia to be called Mandela in just and fitting recognition of our revered and respected President


Seth G. Abraham [CFA.(SA), HDE, B.COM, LL.B]