COMPETITION TRIBUNAL OF SOUTH AFRICA
Case No.: 018291
In the matter between:
PHINDIWE ABEGASL KEMA............................................................................................................First Applicant
AFRICA RACE GROUP (PTY) LTD...............................................................................................Second Applicant
and
NATIONAL HORSERACING AUTHORITY.................................................................................First Respondent
PHUMELELA GAMING AND LEISURE LTD...........................................................................Second Respondent
GOLD CIRCLE (PTY) LTD.............................................................................................................Third Respondent
Panel: Y Carrim (Presiding Member), A Wesseis (Tribunal Member) and M Mokuena (Tribunal Member)
Heard on : 16 October 2014
Decided on : 16 October 2014
COSTS ORDER
1. Noting that the Applicant’s withdrew the matter on 15 October 2014 without a tender of costs; and
2. Having heard the Second and Third Respondents to the application for costs in terms of Tribunal Rule 50(3)(b), the Tribunal orders the following:
2.1. The First and Second Applicants are jointly and severally liable to pay the wasted costs of the Second and Third Respondents, the one paying the other to be absolved;
2.2. The wasted costs are to be paid on a party and party scale, including the costs of two counsel.
17 October 2014 
 Date
Presiding Member
Y Carrim
Concurring: A Wessels and M Mokuena